How Portable Benefits Impact the Gig Economy

By MBO Partners | August 25, 2018

Share
How Portable Benefits Impact the Gig Economy

As the American independent workforce continues to grow, the discussions surrounding non-employee and self-employed benefits and protections continue to gain steam.

A potential solution to this issue, portable benefits, has been receiving significant attention for the last few years.

What are portable benefits?

Portable benefits are a proposed system that would allow an independent contractor, or their clients, to pay into a pooled resource that would provide independents with access to benefits guaranteed to traditional full-time employees. Such benefits would include health insurance and retirement plan options.

Tax benefits

Former DoL Secretary Robert Reich believes a portable benefits system is easily attainable. Citing Obamacare’s success for providing independents health insurance options and opportunities, Reich believes similar options for “income insurance” should be made available as well. Such a proposal suggests tax advantages normally given to employers would be instead applied to the individual worker.

Research efforts in this endeavor have already received DoL funding, and lawmakers in Congress have already looked to receive additional funding for establishing these portable benefits systems.

Funding

The discussed implementation of portable benefits has two potential paths:

  1. Companies hiring independents pay into a fund for each independent (depending on the hours/deliverables to which they are committed). This process creates an obligation for enterprises engaging independents to help provide the entitlements these independents forego by declaring themselves non-employees.
  2. The government sets up a system by which workers could take and retain benefits from client to client. This process would create a seamless option, very similar to how traditional employees gain benefit access with each employer.

Precedents

MBO Partners has been a contributor to the portable benefits conversation since 2008. As part of our suite of services, we have provided the aforementioned entitlements to independents for over a decade (generally referred to as portable employer benefits).

We have looked at the heart of the matter, giving these independent workers the ability to create an employment capability for themselves that can be taken from project to project. Specifically, MBO offers these workers access to the power of their group purchasing to access healthcare, disability and business insurance, as well as 401(k) options for retirement saving. Their “accounts” afford them the ability to secure benefits regardless of type of or number of clients and projects.

Universal Access

It is clear that these benefits can be packaged up properly for the high-earning independents, however, there is a need to focus on those working across working groups that may not have the pricing power to incorporate benefit costs to their bill rates. For example, a ride-share driver or a dog walker may still encounter difficulty in factoring benefits like health care into their own bill rates.

For the independents engaging via a platform (e.g., Uber, Lyft, Handy), the debate lies with whether that marketplace or platform has the “employer” responsibilities. That may depend on how many of the platform workers are truly dependent on this “gig” work as a primary income source. While sharing economy data shows most are supplementing their incomes via these platforms, there remains a portion of individuals fully dependent on the gig economy and thus need protections. Lyft has already created a portable program for retirement benefits, proving that establishing such benefit systems is an achievable endeavor.

In the new gig economy, all parties in a contract must proceed carefully; when independents provide commoditized services, there is a risk that the market will drive the pay of these services, creating a race to the bottom and thus a dangerous environment for those looking to afford certain benefits and entitlements. It is for this market segment where a solution is obviously needed.

As a result, issue at hand for lawmakers is not so much how an independent can obtain or retain benefits – companies like MBO have proven this can already be done – but how much education must be given to show independents at all ends of the spectrum how to properly source and finance these costs. Education – and to some extent, client participation or assistance – may be needed in greater quantities at the lower end of the spectrum.

Legislation

As the debates and conversations continue, portable benefits remains a topic people are hard-pressed to better understand. While intimidating, implementing such a nationwide program does not need heavy lifting or legislation from lawmakers – just the knowledge and technology to successfully execute such programs.

The nuances of worker benefits and protections, however, do present some interesting decisions our government will be pressed to make as the independent contractor population continues to grow. We dive into alternative solutions ourselves, which is detailed in our Certified Self-Employed proposal.

We welcome your thoughts and comments on the situation as well. For more information, or to continue the conversation with our thought leaders, contact us directly.


Find independent consulting jobs with top companies through MBO’s marketplace

Join Today!


Related Posts

consultant older

SIMPLE IRA: Self Employed Contributions and Limits

Self-employed professionals enjoy the flexibility, control, and creativity an independent career offers, but the challenge and uncertainty of planning for retirement is a common concern. At a traditional job, you have the benefit of built-in retirement options, but this field can be more difficult to navigate on your own. Fortunately, there are a number of…

Read More...
consultant talking

4 Options for Home Based Business Insurance

If you’re a self-employed professional working from the comfort of a home office, business insurance may be the last thing on your mind. But most homeowners’ insurance policies don’t cover losses sustained by a home-based business, which can lead to costly claims, unexpected legal expenses, and damages to your company. Self-employed professionals who work from…

Read More...
Benefits

Defined Benefit Plan for the Self-Employed: Pros and Cons

Retirement planning is a top concern for self employed professionals and a defined benefit plan is one of the options to consider. The best option for you will depend on a number of factors including your personal goals and income level, which you can discuss with a financial advisor. What is a Defined Benefit Plan? Think…

Read More...

Trending

Tags

Learn more about the MBO Platform

FOR INDEPENDENT
PROFESSIONALS

Start, run, and grow

your independent business with MBO

FOR
ENTERPRISES

Engage, scale, and optimize

your independent workforce